The Radial Equation & the Hydrogen Atom

4.5 hours ~8 min read

The Radial Equation & the Hydrogen Atom

The angular problem is solved once and forever; what remains is one radial equation per potential. A single substitution, u=rRu = rR, turns it into a one-dimensional Schrödinger equation — every tool from Course P.5 applies — and for the Coulomb potential the series solution terminates only at special energies: 13.6 eV/n2-13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2, Bohr's lucky guess, now derived. This is the calculation that convinced physics that wave mechanics was true. Approach it the way a cat approaches a full food bowl: unhurried, but missing nothing.

Learning Objectives

After this lesson you will be able to:

  1. Reduce a central-potential problem to a 1D equation for u(r)=rR(r)u(r) = rR(r) with the effective potential Veff(r)V_{\text{eff}}(r) and its centrifugal barrier.
  2. Apply the correct boundary conditions on uu and solve the infinite spherical well for =0\ell = 0.
  3. Carry out the full hydrogen solution: asymptotics, series, the recursion relation, and termination.
  4. Derive the Bohr energies En=13.6 eV/n2E_n = -13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2, the Bohr radius a0a_0, and the n2n^2 degeneracy.
  5. Work with the radial functions RnR_{n\ell} and the radial probability density P(r)=r2R2P(r) = r^2|R|^2, computing most probable and mean radii.
  6. Interpret the quantum numbers (n,,m)(n,\ell,m), use spectroscopic notation, and contrast the Bohr and Schrödinger pictures of the atom.

Intuition

Classically, conservation of angular momentum flattens any central-force problem into one-dimensional radial motion in an effective potential V(r)+L2/2mr2V(r) + L^2/2mr^2 — the orbiting piece of the kinetic energy masquerades as a repulsive barrier (P.1.2 Lagrangian Mechanics). Quantum mechanics repeats the maneuver verbatim, with L22(+1)L^2 \to \hbar^2\ell(\ell+1): the electron with angular momentum is pushed away from the origin by the same centrifugal effect that keeps a whirling ball on a string taut.

So the hydrogen atom is, at heart, a Course P.5 problem: a particle in a 1D well (Coulomb attraction plus centrifugal repulsion), with bound states at discrete energies. The magic is in the numbers that come out — energies matching every observed spectral line, and a natural length scale, the Bohr radius, assembled from \hbar, mm, and ee with no free parameters.


Theory

From 3D to effective 1D: the radial equation

Separation in P.6.1 left the radial equation

ddr ⁣(r2dRdr)2mr22[V(r)E]R=(+1)R. \frac{d}{dr}\!\left(r^2\frac{dR}{dr}\right) - \frac{2mr^2}{\hbar^2}\bigl[V(r) - E\bigr]R = \ell(\ell+1)\,R .

Substitute u(r)rR(r)u(r) \equiv r\,R(r). Then R=u/rR = u/r, dRdr=urur2\dfrac{dR}{dr} = \dfrac{u'}{r} - \dfrac{u}{r^2}, so r2dRdr=ruur^2\dfrac{dR}{dr} = r u' - u and ddr(ruu)=ru\dfrac{d}{dr}\bigl(r u' - u\bigr) = r u''. The equation becomes ru2mr2(VE)u=(+1)urr u'' - \frac{2mr}{\hbar^2}(V - E)\,u = \ell(\ell+1)\,\frac{u}{r}, i.e.

22md2udr2+[V(r)+2(+1)2mr2]Veff(r)u=Eu. -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{d^2u}{dr^2} + \underbrace{\left[V(r) + \frac{\hbar^2\ell(\ell+1)}{2mr^2}\right]}_{V_{\text{eff}}(r)} u = E\,u .

This is exactly a 1D Schrödinger equation, with VV replaced by the effective potential: the true potential plus the centrifugal barrier 2(+1)/2mr2\hbar^2\ell(\ell+1)/2mr^2 — the same L2/2mr2L^2/2mr^2 term as in the classical central-force problem (P.1.2), quantized. Normalization also cooperates: ψ2d3r=0R2r2dr=0u2dr=1\int|\psi|^2 d^3r = \int_0^\infty |R|^2 r^2 dr = \int_0^\infty |u|^2 dr = 1.

Boundary conditions: the 1D toolkit applies

Two conditions replace the free constants of the 1D problems:

  • At the origin: u(0)=0u(0) = 0. If u(0)0u(0)\ne 0 then Ru(0)/rR \sim u(0)/r, and 2(1/r)=4πδ3(r)\nabla^2(1/r) = -4\pi\delta^3(\mathbf r) produces a delta function no finite VV can cancel — not a solution. (For >0\ell > 0 the centrifugal barrier enforces even faster vanishing, as we'll see.)
  • At infinity: u0u \to 0 for a bound state (E<V()E < V(\infty)), just as in P.5.2 Step, Well & Barrier.

With uu vanishing at both ends, all the machinery of Course P.5 — node counting, matching, shooting-method numerics — transfers wholesale to three dimensions.

Warm-up: the infinite spherical well

Let V(r)=0V(r) = 0 for r<ar < a and \infty outside. For =0\ell = 0 the radial equation is just u=k2uu'' = -k^2 u with k=2mE/k = \sqrt{2mE}/\hbar — the 1D box. The condition u(0)=0u(0) = 0 selects u=Asin(kr)u = A\sin(kr), and u(a)=0u(a) = 0 quantizes k=nπ/ak = n\pi/a:

En=n2π222ma2,n=1,2,3, E_n = \frac{n^2\pi^2\hbar^2}{2ma^2}, \qquad n = 1, 2, 3, \dots

with Rn0=Asin(nπr/a)/rR_{n0} = A\sin(n\pi r/a)/r, perfectly finite at the origin. For >0\ell > 0 the solutions regular at r=0r=0 are the spherical Bessel functions, Rj(kr)R \propto j_\ell(kr), and the energies come from their zeros — Exercise E5 works out =1\ell = 1.

The hydrogen atom I: setting up

Now the main event. The proton's Coulomb potential is

V(r)=e24πϵ01r, V(r) = -\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\frac1r ,

so the radial equation reads

22md2udr2+[e24πϵ0r+2(+1)2mr2]u=Eu. -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{d^2u}{dr^2} + \left[-\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0 r} + \frac{\hbar^2\ell(\ell+1)}{2mr^2}\right]u = E\,u .

Bound states have E<0E < 0. Define

κ2mE,ρκr,ρ0me22πϵ02κ, \kappa \equiv \frac{\sqrt{-2mE}}{\hbar}, \qquad \rho \equiv \kappa r, \qquad \rho_0 \equiv \frac{me^2}{2\pi\epsilon_0\hbar^2\kappa} ,

(κ\kappa is real; ρ\rho is dimensionless radius; ρ0\rho_0 packages the strength of the Coulomb attraction relative to the energy). Dividing the equation by EE and tidying up:

d2udρ2=[1ρ0ρ+(+1)ρ2]u. \frac{d^2u}{d\rho^2} = \left[1 - \frac{\rho_0}{\rho} + \frac{\ell(\ell+1)}{\rho^2}\right]u .

The hydrogen atom II: asymptotics and the series

Large ρ\rho: the bracket 1\to 1, so uuu'' \approx u and uAeρ+Beρu \sim Ae^{-\rho} + Be^{\rho}; normalizability kills BB. Small ρ\rho: the centrifugal term dominates, u(+1)ρ2uu'' \approx \dfrac{\ell(\ell+1)}{\rho^2}u, with solutions ρ+1\rho^{\ell+1} and ρ\rho^{-\ell}; the second violates u(0)=0u(0) = 0 (and normalizability), so uCρ+1u \sim C\rho^{\ell+1}. Peel off both behaviors:

u(ρ)=ρ+1eρv(ρ). u(\rho) = \rho^{\ell+1}\,e^{-\rho}\,v(\rho) .

Substituting (two applications of the product rule) turns the equation for uu into

ρd2vdρ2+2(+1ρ)dvdρ+[ρ02(+1)]v=0. \rho\,\frac{d^2v}{d\rho^2} + 2(\ell + 1 - \rho)\,\frac{dv}{d\rho} + \bigl[\rho_0 - 2(\ell+1)\bigr]v = 0 .

Try a power series v(ρ)=j=0cjρjv(\rho) = \sum_{j=0}^\infty c_j\rho^j. Then ρv=jj(j+1)cj+1ρj\rho\,v'' = \sum_j j(j+1)c_{j+1}\rho^j, 2(+1)v=j2(+1)(j+1)cj+1ρj2(\ell+1)v' = \sum_j 2(\ell+1)(j+1)c_{j+1}\rho^j, and 2ρv=j2jcjρj-2\rho v' = -\sum_j 2j\,c_j\rho^j (each after shifting the summation index). Collecting the coefficient of ρj\rho^j:

j(j+1)cj+1+2(+1)(j+1)cj+12jcj+[ρ02(+1)]cj=0, j(j+1)c_{j+1} + 2(\ell+1)(j+1)c_{j+1} - 2j\,c_j + \bigl[\rho_0 - 2(\ell+1)\bigr]c_j = 0 ,

which solves to the recursion relation

cj+1=2(j++1)ρ0(j+1)(j+2+2)  cj. c_{j+1} = \frac{2(j + \ell + 1) - \rho_0}{(j+1)(j + 2\ell + 2)}\;c_j .

One constant c0c_0 (fixed later by normalization) generates the whole series.

The hydrogen atom III: quantization

Suppose the series never terminates. For large jj the recursion is cj+12j+1cjc_{j+1} \approx \dfrac{2}{j+1}c_j, whose solution is cj2jj!c0c_j \approx \dfrac{2^j}{j!}c_0 — the series of c0e2ρc_0e^{2\rho}. Then uc0ρ+1eρe2ρ=c0ρ+1e+ρu \approx c_0\,\rho^{\ell+1}e^{-\rho}e^{2\rho} = c_0\,\rho^{\ell+1}e^{+\rho}: the asymptotic disease we amputated grows back. The only escape is termination: some maximal index jmaxj_{\max} must give cjmax+1=0c_{j_{\max}+1} = 0, i.e.

2(jmax++1)=ρ0. 2(j_{\max} + \ell + 1) = \rho_0 .

Define the principal quantum number njmax++1{1,2,3,}n \equiv j_{\max} + \ell + 1 \in \{1, 2, 3, \dots\}, so ρ0=2n\rho_0 = 2n. Unpacking ρ0\rho_0's definition, κ=me24πϵ02n\kappa = \dfrac{me^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0\hbar^2 n}, and E=2κ22mE = -\dfrac{\hbar^2\kappa^2}{2m} gives

En=[m22(e24πϵ0)2]1n2=13.6 eVn2,n=1,2,3, E_n = -\left[\frac{m}{2\hbar^2}\left(\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\right)^2\right]\frac{1}{n^2} = -\frac{13.6\ \text{eV}}{n^2}, \qquad n = 1, 2, 3, \dots

— the Bohr formula, exactly, but derived from a real dynamical theory rather than postulated. The natural length scale also assembles itself: κ=1/(a0n)\kappa = 1/(a_0 n) with

a0=4πϵ02me2=0.529 A˚=5.29×1011 m, a_0 = \frac{4\pi\epsilon_0\hbar^2}{me^2} = 0.529\ \text{Å} = 5.29\times10^{-11}\ \text{m},

the Bohr radius. Two structural facts come free. Since jmax=n10j_{\max} = n - \ell - 1 \ge 0,

n1(=0,1,,n1), \ell \le n - 1 \qquad (\ell = 0, 1, \dots, n-1),

and counting all states at energy EnE_n (2+12\ell+1 values of mm for each allowed \ell):

d(n)==0n1(2+1)=2(n1)n2+n=n2. d(n) = \sum_{\ell=0}^{n-1}(2\ell + 1) = 2\cdot\frac{(n-1)n}{2} + n = n^2 .

The mm-degeneracy is guaranteed by spherical symmetry; the extra \ell-degeneracy (2s degenerate with 2p) is an "accident" special to the pure 1/r1/r potential.

The wavefunctions

The terminating polynomials v(ρ)v(\rho) are (up to normalization) the associated Laguerre polynomials Ln12+1(2ρ)L_{n-\ell-1}^{2\ell+1}(2\rho), with ρ=r/na0\rho = r/na_0, so ψnm=Rn(r)Ym(θ,φ)\psi_{n\ell m} = R_{n\ell}(r)\,Y_\ell^m(\theta,\varphi) with Rn=ρ+1eρv(ρ)/rR_{n\ell} = \rho^{\ell+1}e^{-\rho}v(\rho)/r. The first few, normalized:

R10=2a03/2er/a0,R20=12a03/2(1r2a0)er/2a0,R21=124a03/2ra0er/2a0. R_{10} = \frac{2}{a_0^{3/2}}\,e^{-r/a_0}, \qquad R_{20} = \frac{1}{\sqrt2\,a_0^{3/2}}\left(1 - \frac{r}{2a_0}\right)e^{-r/2a_0}, \qquad R_{21} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{24}\,a_0^{3/2}}\,\frac{r}{a_0}\,e^{-r/2a_0}.

The physically meaningful radial quantity is the radial probability density

P(r)=r2R(r)2, P(r) = r^2\,|R(r)|^2 ,

the probability per unit radius of finding the electron in the spherical shell [r,r+dr][r, r+dr] (the r2r^2 is the shell's growing area). For the ground state, P(r)=4a03r2e2r/a0P(r) = \frac{4}{a_0^3}r^2e^{-2r/a_0}; setting dP/dr=0dP/dr = 0 gives 2re2r/a0(1r/a0)=02re^{-2r/a_0}(1 - r/a_0) = 0, so the most probable radius is exactly a0a_0 — Bohr's orbit radius reborn as the peak of a distribution. The mean radius is larger, because the distribution has a long tail:

r=0rP(r)dr=4a030r3e2r/a0dr=4a033!(a02)4=32a0. \langle r\rangle = \int_0^\infty r\,P(r)\,dr = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\int_0^\infty r^3 e^{-2r/a_0}dr = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\cdot 3!\left(\frac{a_0}{2}\right)^4 = \frac32\,a_0 .

Caution. The electron is not "at the Bohr radius," and it is not on a trajectory at all — P(r)drP(r)\,dr is the probability of finding it in a shell upon measurement, per the Born rule (P.4.1). And do not confuse R2|R|^2 with r2R2r^2|R|^2: the ground-state density ψ1002e2r/a0|\psi_{100}|^2 \propto e^{-2r/a_0} peaks at r=0r = 0, while P(r)P(r) peaks at a0a_0. Both statements are true; they answer different questions.

Quantum numbers, notation, and Bohr vs Schrödinger

Symbol Name Allowed values Determines
nn principal 1,2,3,1, 2, 3, \dots energy En=13.6 eV/n2E_n = -13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2
\ell orbital (azimuthal) 0,1,,n10, 1, \dots, n-1 shape; L=(+1)\lvert\mathbf L\rvert = \hbar\sqrt{\ell(\ell+1)}
mm magnetic ,,+-\ell, \dots, +\ell orientation; Lz=mL_z = m\hbar

Spectroscopic notation labels =0,1,2,3,\ell = 0,1,2,3,\dots as s,p,d,f,s, p, d, f,\dots prefixed by nn: the ground state is 1s; the n=2n=2 level holds 2s and 2p; and so on.

Bohr model (P.2.2) Schrödinger theory
Energies 13.6 eV/n2-13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2 (right, luckily) same — now derived
Angular momentum L=nL = n\hbar; ground state L=L = \hbar L=(+1)\lvert\mathbf L\rvert = \hbar\sqrt{\ell(\ell+1)}; ground state =0\ell = 0, L=0L = 0!
Picture planetary orbits of definite radius stationary probability clouds ("orbitals, not orbits")
States per level one orbit n2n^2 degenerate states (n,,m)(n,\ell,m)

The Rydberg formula, fitted to data in P.2.2, is now a theorem: a photon emitted in the transition ninfn_i \to n_f carries hν=EniEnfh\nu = E_{n_i} - E_{n_f}, so

1λ=RH(1nf21ni2),RH=m4πc3(e24πϵ0)2=1.097×107 m1. \frac{1}{\lambda} = R_H\left(\frac{1}{n_f^2} - \frac{1}{n_i^2}\right), \qquad R_H = \frac{m}{4\pi c\hbar^3}\left(\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\right)^2 = 1.097\times10^7\ \text{m}^{-1}.

Not every pair of levels actually radiates, though: coupling to the electromagnetic field enforces the selection rule Δ=±1\Delta\ell = \pm1 (2p → 1s shines; 2s → 1s is forbidden and that state is metastable). Deriving this requires time-dependent perturbation theory, beyond our scope here.


Worked Examples

Example 1 — Lyman-α from first principles

The n=21n = 2 \to 1 transition emits ΔE=E2E1=3.40(13.6)=10.2 eV\Delta E = E_2 - E_1 = -3.40 - (-13.6) = 10.2\ \text{eV}. The wavelength: λ=hc/ΔE=(1240 eV⋅nm)/10.2 eV=121.6 nm\lambda = hc/\Delta E = (1240\ \text{eV·nm})/10.2\ \text{eV} = 121.6\ \text{nm} — deep ultraviolet, matching the measured Lyman-α line (121.567 nm121.567\ \text{nm}) to our precision. The same arithmetic on 323\to2, 424\to2, ... reproduces the visible Balmer series a century of spectroscopists catalogued.

Example 2 — Where is the ground-state electron?

What is the probability of finding it beyond the Bohr radius? With x=2r/a0x = 2r/a_0:

P(r>a0)=4a03a0r2e2r/a0dr=122x2exdx=12[(x2+2x+2)ex]2=10e22=5e20.677. P(r > a_0) = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\int_{a_0}^\infty r^2 e^{-2r/a_0}\,dr = \frac12\int_2^\infty x^2 e^{-x}\,dx = \frac12\Bigl[-(x^2 + 2x + 2)e^{-x}\Bigr]_2^\infty = \frac{10\,e^{-2}}{2} = 5e^{-2} \approx 0.677 .

Two-thirds of measurements find the electron outside the "orbit" it supposedly occupies. The Bohr radius marks the peak of P(r)P(r), not a boundary — the atom has no edge, only an exponential fade.


Hands-on (Python)

Shooting method on u(r)u(r), in Bohr-radius units where the equation becomes u=[(+1)/x22/xε]uu'' = [\ell(\ell+1)/x^2 - 2/x - \varepsilon]u with ε=E/(13.6 eV)\varepsilon = E/(13.6\ \text{eV}):

import numpy as np

def shoot(eps, l, x_max=40.0, n=8000):
    """Integrate u'' = k(x) u outward; return u(x_max). Eigenvalue <=> u(x_max) ~ 0."""
    x = np.linspace(1e-4, x_max, n); h = x[1] - x[0]
    k = l*(l + 1)/x**2 - 2.0/x - eps
    u = np.zeros(n); u[0], u[1] = x[0]**(l + 1), x[1]**(l + 1)   # u ~ x^{l+1} near 0
    for i in range(1, n - 1):
        u[i+1] = 2*u[i] - u[i-1] + h*h*k[i]*u[i]
    return u[-1]

def eigenvalue(l, lo, hi):
    for _ in range(60):                       # bisect on the sign of u(x_max)
        mid = 0.5*(lo + hi)
        if shoot(lo, l)*shoot(mid, l) < 0: hi = mid
        else: lo = mid
    return 0.5*(lo + hi)

for l, brackets in [(0, [(-1.5, -0.6), (-0.35, -0.15), (-0.14, -0.09)]),
                    (1, [(-0.35, -0.15), (-0.14, -0.09)])]:
    print(l, [round(eigenvalue(l, *b)*13.6057, 2) for b in brackets])
# Expect: l=0 -> [-13.61, -3.40, -1.51];  l=1 -> [-3.40, -1.51]
# E depends only on n -- the accidental Coulomb degeneracy, found numerically.

Radial probability densities P(r)=r2R2P(r) = r^2R^2 in units of a0a_0:

import matplotlib.pyplot as plt

r = np.linspace(0, 25, 1000)                                # r in units of a0
R = {(1,0): 2*np.exp(-r),
     (2,0): (1 - r/2)*np.exp(-r/2)/np.sqrt(2),
     (2,1): r*np.exp(-r/2)/np.sqrt(24),
     (3,0): (2/np.sqrt(27))*(1 - 2*r/3 + 2*r**2/27)*np.exp(-r/3)}
for (n, l), Rnl in R.items():
    plt.plot(r, r**2*Rnl**2, label=f"$P_{{{n}{l}}}$")
plt.xlabel("$r/a_0$"); plt.ylabel("$P(r)\\,a_0$"); plt.legend(); plt.show()
# Expect: P_10 peaks at r = a0; P_20 has a node (2 bumps); P_21 one bump peaking
# at 4 a0; P_30 has two nodes. Check each curve integrates to 1 with np.trapezoid.

Monte Carlo orbital clouds — rejection-sample ψ2|\psi|^2 and scatter the points:

rng = np.random.default_rng(7)

def psi2_210(x, y, z):                       # |psi_210|^2 ∝ e^{-r} z^2   (a0 = 1)
    return np.exp(-np.sqrt(x*x + y*y + z*z))*z**2

def psi2_320(x, y, z):                       # |psi_320|^2 ∝ r^4 e^{-2r/3}(3cos^2θ - 1)^2
    r = np.sqrt(x*x + y*y + z*z)
    return r**4*np.exp(-2*r/3)*(3*(z/np.maximum(r, 1e-12))**2 - 1)**2

def sample(pdf, half_box, f_max, n_keep=4000):
    kept = np.empty((0, 3))
    while len(kept) < n_keep:                # rejection sampling in a cube
        p = rng.uniform(-half_box, half_box, (100_000, 3))
        acc = p[rng.uniform(0, f_max, 100_000) < pdf(*p.T)]
        kept = np.vstack([kept, acc])
    return kept[:n_keep]

fig = plt.figure(figsize=(11, 5))
for i, (pdf, box, fmax, name) in enumerate(
        [(psi2_210, 15, 0.6, "2p$_z$"), (psi2_320, 30, 95.0, "3d$_{z^2}$")]):
    pts = sample(pdf, box, fmax)
    ax = fig.add_subplot(1, 2, i + 1, projection='3d')
    ax.scatter(*pts.T, s=1, alpha=0.3); ax.set_title(name)
plt.show()
# Expect: the 2p_z dumbbell along z; the 3d_z2 dumbbell wearing a donut at the
# waist -- the textbook orbital pictures, generated from |psi|^2 itself.

Exercises

E1 (easy). Compute the wavelength of the Balmer H-α line (n=32n = 3 \to 2). Which part of the spectrum is it in?

Solution

ΔE=13.6(1419)=13.6536=1.89 eV\Delta E = 13.6\left(\frac14 - \frac19\right) = 13.6\cdot\frac{5}{36} = 1.89\ \text{eV}; λ=1240/1.89=656 nm\lambda = 1240/1.89 = 656\ \text{nm} — red, visible; the famous H-α line of astronomy.

E2 (easy). Verify by explicit integration that R10R_{10} is normalized: 0R102r2dr=1\int_0^\infty R_{10}^2\,r^2\,dr = 1.

Solution

$\int_0^\infty \frac{4}{a_0^3}e^{-2r/a_0}r^2dr = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\cdot\frac{2!}{(2/a_0)^3} = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\cdot\frac{2a_0^3}{8} = 1(using ✓ (using \int_0^\infty r^ne^{-br}dr = n!/b^{n+1}$).

E3 (medium). Find the most probable radius of the 2p state (R21R_{21}) and compare with the Bohr model's prediction for n=2n = 2.

Solution

P(r)r2R212r4er/a0P(r) \propto r^2R_{21}^2 \propto r^4e^{-r/a_0}. Then dP/dr(4r3r4/a0)er/a0=0dP/dr \propto (4r^3 - r^4/a_0)e^{-r/a_0} = 0 gives r=4a0r = 4a_0 — exactly Bohr's n2a0n^2a_0 for n=2n = 2. The circular Bohr orbit survives as the peak of the maximal-\ell radial distribution; small-\ell states (like 2s) have no classical counterpart at all.

E4 (medium). For the ground state compute 1/r\langle 1/r\rangle, then V\langle V\rangle and T\langle T\rangle. Verify the virial pattern V=2E1\langle V\rangle = 2E_1, T=E1\langle T\rangle = -E_1.

Solution

1/r=4a030re2r/a0dr=4a03a024=1a0\langle 1/r\rangle = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\int_0^\infty r\,e^{-2r/a_0}dr = \frac{4}{a_0^3}\cdot\frac{a_0^2}{4} = \frac{1}{a_0}. So V=e24πϵ01/r=e24πϵ0a0=27.2 eV=2E1\langle V\rangle = -\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\langle 1/r\rangle = -\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0 a_0} = -27.2\ \text{eV} = 2E_1, and T=E1V=13.6+27.2=+13.6 eV=E1\langle T\rangle = E_1 - \langle V\rangle = -13.6 + 27.2 = +13.6\ \text{eV} = -E_1 ✓ — the quantum virial theorem for a 1/r1/r potential, 2T=V2\langle T\rangle = -\langle V\rangle.

E5 (hard). Solve the infinite spherical well for =1\ell = 1: show that u(r)=A[sin(kr)/(kr)cos(kr)]u(r) = A\bigl[\sin(kr)/(kr) - \cos(kr)\bigr] satisfies the radial equation and the origin condition, derive the quantization condition, and compare the lowest =1\ell=1 energy to the =0\ell=0 ground state.

Solution

With u=sin(kr)/(kr)cos(kr)u = \sin(kr)/(kr) - \cos(kr) (this is krj1(kr)kr\,j_1(kr)), differentiating twice gives u=ksinkrr2coskrr2+2sinkrkr3+k2coskru'' = -\frac{k\sin kr}{r} - \frac{2\cos kr}{r^2} + \frac{2\sin kr}{kr^3} + k^2\cos kr, while (k22r2)u=ksinkrrk2coskr2sinkrkr3+2coskrr2\bigl(k^2 - \frac{2}{r^2}\bigr)u = \frac{k\sin kr}{r} - k^2\cos kr - \frac{2\sin kr}{kr^3} + \frac{2\cos kr}{r^2}; the sum vanishes term by term, so u+[k22/r2]u=0u'' + \bigl[k^2 - 2/r^2\bigr]u = 0 — the =1\ell = 1 radial equation with V=0V = 0. As r0r\to0, sin(kr)/(kr)1(kr)2/6\sin(kr)/(kr) \to 1 - (kr)^2/6 and cos(kr)1(kr)2/2\cos(kr)\to 1 - (kr)^2/2, so u(kr)2/30u \to (kr)^2/3 \to 0 ✓ (indeed ur+1u\sim r^{\ell+1}). The wall imposes u(a)=0u(a) = 0: tan(ka)=ka\tan(ka) = ka, whose smallest positive root is ka4.4934ka \approx 4.4934. Hence E1,=1=(4.4934)22/2ma220.22/2ma2E_{1,\ell=1} = (4.4934)^2\hbar^2/2ma^2 \approx 20.2\,\hbar^2/2ma^2, about 2.05×2.05\times the =0\ell = 0 ground energy π22/2ma29.872/2ma2\pi^2\hbar^2/2ma^2 \approx 9.87\,\hbar^2/2ma^2 — the centrifugal barrier raises every =1\ell = 1 level, and unlike hydrogen there is no accidental degeneracy.


Checkpoint

  1. What is Veff(r)V_{\text{eff}}(r), and where does its extra term come from — classically and quantum mechanically?
  2. Why must u(0)=0u(0) = 0?
  3. Trace the logic: how does demanding a normalizable solution produce En=13.6 eV/n2E_n = -13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2?
  4. Why is the degeneracy of level nn equal to n2n^2, and which part of it is "accidental"?
  5. The ground-state ψ2|\psi|^2 peaks at r=0r = 0 but P(r)P(r) peaks at a0a_0. Reconcile.
Answers
  1. Veff=V(r)+2(+1)/2mr2V_{\text{eff}} = V(r) + \hbar^2\ell(\ell+1)/2mr^2. The barrier is the angular kinetic energy: classically L2/2mr2L^2/2mr^2 from conservation of L\mathbf L; quantum mechanically the L^2/2mr2\hat L^2/2mr^2 term acting on YmY_\ell^m.
  2. Otherwise R1/rR\sim1/r and 2ψ\nabla^2\psi contains 4πδ3(r)-4\pi\delta^3(\mathbf r), which nothing in the equation can balance; the wavefunction would not solve the Schrödinger equation at the origin.
  3. Asymptotics force u=ρ+1eρvu = \rho^{\ell+1}e^{-\rho}v; the series for vv obeys cj+1=2(j++1)ρ0(j+1)(j+2+2)cjc_{j+1} = \frac{2(j+\ell+1)-\rho_0}{(j+1)(j+2\ell+2)}c_j; a non-terminating series grows like e2ρe^{2\rho} and ruins normalizability; termination forces ρ0=2n\rho_0 = 2n, which converts to En1/n2E_n \propto -1/n^2.
  4. d(n)==0n1(2+1)=n2d(n) = \sum_{\ell=0}^{n-1}(2\ell+1) = n^2. The 2+12\ell+1 mm-degeneracy follows from rotational symmetry; the degeneracy across different \ell is accidental, special to the 1/r1/r potential.
  5. They answer different questions: ψ2|\psi|^2 is probability per unit volume (largest at the origin), P(r)=4πr2ψ2P(r) = 4\pi r^2|\psi|^2 is probability per unit radius, and the growing shell area r2\propto r^2 moves its peak out to a0a_0.

Further Reading

  • [Gri] Griffiths & Schroeter, §4.2 — the hydrogen atom; this lesson follows its route and notation (κ\kappa, ρ\rho, ρ0\rho_0).
  • [ER] Eisberg & Resnick, Ch. 7 — one-electron atoms with full experimental context and the classic orbital plots.
  • [Gold] Goldstein, Poole & Safko, Ch. 3 — the classical central-force problem; compare the effective potentials side by side.
  • [Sha] Shankar, Ch. 13 — the hydrogen atom, with a sharper look at the accidental degeneracy and its hidden symmetry.

← Prev: Central Potentials & Orbital Angular Momentum · Up: Pre-Term · Next: Magnetic Moments, Stern–Gerlach & Spin

Ready to measure your state?

5 exercises · 10 checkpoint questions

Start the quiz